- Posts: 173
× Members
safely for pip
- an ex nurse
- Topic Author
- Away
Less More
1 day 55 minutes ago #307570 by an ex nurse
safely for pip was created by an ex nurse
I received my pip review result and scored 10 for the moving around section. I am considering an MR and wondered if the safety rule means you would always have to be accompanied outside.
Due to some treatment I have fragile bones in my leg that are prone to fracture and also 2 unstable spinal fractures. I have foot drop and trip a lot when walking even with a stick. Any fall could have an increased risk of injury as any leg fracture may not heal and I could suffer further spinal damage. I don't feel this has been taken into account. Can this be sufficient grounds for an MR or would I be wasting my time as I am not in a position to always be accompanied when I go out.
Staggeringly part of the information they had used was an ESA assessment from over 10 years ago despite me sending current evidence.
I am grateful for any advice, many thanks
Due to some treatment I have fragile bones in my leg that are prone to fracture and also 2 unstable spinal fractures. I have foot drop and trip a lot when walking even with a stick. Any fall could have an increased risk of injury as any leg fracture may not heal and I could suffer further spinal damage. I don't feel this has been taken into account. Can this be sufficient grounds for an MR or would I be wasting my time as I am not in a position to always be accompanied when I go out.
Staggeringly part of the information they had used was an ESA assessment from over 10 years ago despite me sending current evidence.
I am grateful for any advice, many thanks
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- BIS
- Offline
Less More
- Posts: 9514
14 hours 27 minutes ago #307593 by BIS
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
Replied by BIS on topic safely for pip
Hi an ex nurse
Only you can decide whether or not its worth putting in for an MR - you're the expert on your condition and understand the impact.
It's quite possible for someone to need to be accompanied, but not have anyone - so you shouldn't let that stop you from challenging the decision. From the little you've said, I would be argue that the assessor has misunderstood the severity of your condition - and argue something like this:
"Fragility and Risk of Re-injury: Due to treatment-related complications, I have fragile bones in my leg and two unstable spinal fractures. This means that even a minor fall could cause serious or irreversible harm. A leg fracture may not heal properly, and I face a very real risk of further spinal damage.
Mobility Limitations: I suffer from foot drop, which makes walking difficult and increases my risk of tripping, even with a walking stick. This significantly affects my balance and coordination.
Pain and Fatigue: I experience ongoing pain, and the physical effort required to walk—even short distances—is both exhausting and distressing. My walking pace is considerably slower than average, and I cannot repeat movements or walk even a short distance without considerable strain or danger. Even when I am accompanied, it does not prevent me from tripping. "
You don't have to use those exact words - you get the picture and as I said you're the expert.
Good luck with whatever you decide.
BIS
Only you can decide whether or not its worth putting in for an MR - you're the expert on your condition and understand the impact.
It's quite possible for someone to need to be accompanied, but not have anyone - so you shouldn't let that stop you from challenging the decision. From the little you've said, I would be argue that the assessor has misunderstood the severity of your condition - and argue something like this:
"Fragility and Risk of Re-injury: Due to treatment-related complications, I have fragile bones in my leg and two unstable spinal fractures. This means that even a minor fall could cause serious or irreversible harm. A leg fracture may not heal properly, and I face a very real risk of further spinal damage.
Mobility Limitations: I suffer from foot drop, which makes walking difficult and increases my risk of tripping, even with a walking stick. This significantly affects my balance and coordination.
Pain and Fatigue: I experience ongoing pain, and the physical effort required to walk—even short distances—is both exhausting and distressing. My walking pace is considerably slower than average, and I cannot repeat movements or walk even a short distance without considerable strain or danger. Even when I am accompanied, it does not prevent me from tripping. "
You don't have to use those exact words - you get the picture and as I said you're the expert.
Good luck with whatever you decide.
BIS
Nothing on this board constitutes legal advice - always consult a professional about specific problems
The following user(s) said Thank You: an ex nurse
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Moderators: Gordon, latetrain, BIS, Catherine, Chris, David, Keely