The High Court has ruled that Somerset Council’s decision to hike a claimant’s council tax liability after migration from employment and support allowance (ESA) to universal credit (UC)was unlawful, irrational and discriminatory.  The judgement may be relevant to claimants living in other local authorities and readers should seek advice if you have been hit with a rise in similar circumstances

Back in April 2026, we reported on the case of Andy Mitchell. 

Andy did not have to pay council tax under Somerset Council’s reduction scheme, in recognition of his disability. However, after his migration to UC, he received a reduction of only around £2 per week, meaning his council tax bill was more than £1,100 per year – despite there being no change in his level of income or his needs. 

This was because two elements of his Universal Credit, the limited capability for work related activity element and the transitional element, which he receives as a result of his disability, were suddenly counted as spare income for the purposes of calculating his ability to pay council tax.

Andy challenged the ruling, represented by Leigh Day solicitors, who argued that Somerset’s council tax reduction scheme was unlawful because it treated migrated claimants differently to disabled people claiming legacy benefits and non-disabled people claiming UC.

They also argued that the council had failed to properly consider the impact of its scheme on disabled people, as required by the Equality Act.

The challenge was successful, with the judge ruling that Somerset’s rules are irrational and discriminatory because they treat people with the same needs differently solely on the basis of which type of benefit they receive.  The judge quashed the council’s decision on Andy’s council tax and ordered them to reassess him.  And this time they will have to do it fairly.

Andy Mitchell said: 

“Today’s judgment is a huge relief. When I was moved onto Universal Credit, I was told that my income would be protected and that I would not be worse off financially. Yet I suddenly found myself facing a council tax bill of more than £1,000 a year despite nothing changing about my health, circumstances or needs. 

“I brought this case because I believed that could not be right, and I am delighted that the court has agreed. I know there are many other disabled benefit claimants who have experienced the same shock after moving onto Universal Credit and struggled to meet their council tax liability. I hope this judgment helps ensure that people are treated fairly and that no one is penalised simply because of the type of benefit they receive. This is money the council should never have demanded from thousands of disabled people across Somerset.” 

The judgment could have implications for other local authorities which operate similar council tax reduction schemes.

If you've been moved from ESA to UC and your council tax bill has increased as a result, it would be worth getting advice about whether you can challenge the rise.

Leigh Day is inviting people who believe they have been affected by similar council tax reduction rules to contact them at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..

You may also be able to get free help from an advice agency or law centre in your area. If you need legal representation, you can check whether you're eligible for legal aid.

Comments

Write comments...
or post as a guest
People in conversation:
Loading comment... The comment will be refreshed after 00:00.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 2 hours ago
    While on ESA, we were getting 100% discount. As soon as we were moved to UC, we get £6/week discount. Paying £1000+ to Leicester City Council.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 5 hours ago
    This resonates with my experience as I was migrated to UC from legacy benefits last May and had no prior warning this would affect my claim in this way.
    The housing association benefits advisor who helped with the transition form must have had no knowledge of this either as understood I would be better off under the UC system according to her.
    Imagine the unwelcome surprise when 1 month later I received a revised council tax bill from Somerset Council that had increased from £0 to £1044 for the year.
    Hopefully, Andy Mitchell's successful legal challenge will resonate down and this punitive application will be cancelled.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 5 hours ago
    The same thing happened to me. Leicester City Council sent me a CT bill at the beginning of the year saying I now would pay £0. In the summer I got migrated to UC abd they hit me with a bill for £100 a month. I applied for discretionary relief and they rejected my claim. I'm much worse off now. 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 2 days ago
    I used to be 100% do't have to pay council tax because I was on income related ESA, Housing Benefits and DLA before migrated to UC as the council tax went up have to pay £100 a month because they say they do counted DLA as income. I am now worse off not better off on UC.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 3 days ago
    I dont understand what they are doing.  It is so complicated and they just keep adding more and more bits to it all that make it more complicated still.  For a while i could keep up, since the migration, i am lost completely.  Its too much.  Its so hard to function most of the time, and this on top just even makes it harder.  What is wrong with them?
    I read the guardian article and it said 55% of welfare is pensioners, and 2.5% young ppl (not going to use that terrible phrase thats become common place).  So how can they take from those young ppl, whilst leaving in place a pension that many of those 55% dont need...because they have private pensions.  And then the young ppl are expected to pay for those pensions, and what are they getting?  
    Madness. Why cant we just go on 'enough'...who has it, and who doesnt.  Base it on that.  Enough for food, housing, warmth, water. 

    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 1 days ago
      @keepingitreal Indeed
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 2 days ago
      @Bob Most pensioners in the UK receive more in state pension and related benefits over the course of their retirement than they paid into the system in National Insurance (NI) contributions.

      Key Facts About Pension Contributions and Payouts

      • The "Pay-As-You-Go" System: State pension contributions are not ring-fenced or saved into an individual pot. Instead, current National Insurance payments from workers fund the state pensions of current retirees.

      • What Studies Show: Research from organizations like the Pensions Policy Institute (PPI) indicates that almost everyone receives significantly more back in state pension payments than they contributed via National Insurance over their working life.

      • Who Breaks Even? According to studies cited by the Workplace Journal, the rare exception is typically a high-earning male (in the top 10% of earners) who has a shorter-than-average retirement lifespan. Conversely, women (due to longer average life expectancies and lower average lifetime earnings) and lower earners or those with employment gaps routinely receive far more than they put in.

      • Public Perception vs. Reality: A YouGov study highlighted that only 15% of the public realize pensioners get more out of the state pension than they pay in, with nearly 43% falsely believing the average retiree gets back less than they contributed. Online community discussions on platforms like Reddit r/ukpolitics also show a consensus that the current structure—combined with longer life expectancies and the state pension "triple lock"—places a heavy financial burden on the working-age population.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 2 days ago
      @Bob Yes, and any income derived, or which could be derived from them is deducted from pension credit or housing benefit, so if your private pension is too small to take you out of means tested benefits you lose the value of your private pension pot.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      · 2 days ago
      @DJMH15 Those 55% have paid tax and NI and entiltled to the state pension, most private pensions in reality are very small.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 4 days ago
    The first piece of good news I’ve seen on here for quite some time. I’ve a feeling there will be legal challenges aplenty to come on many of the aspects of the so called reforms (cuts) that are coming.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    · 4 days ago
    I got hit with 2 month's rent owing because the housing association accepted housing benefit in arrears but required UC HA to be paid in advance, which it isn't so I had to make up the difference, added to the 3 week gap in HA due to the 5 week wait plus 2 weeks extra HB I ended up having to pay over £1100 for my rent. They migrated us without any planning or care about what happened to us after.

PIP & The WCA Are Changing- Get The Latest News

Stay updated with our free, fortnightly newsletter.

Over 140,000 claimant and professional subscribers.

 
iContact