Benefits and Work has started receiving emails from readers concerned that disability benefits including PIP, DLA and AA are about to be means-tested.

Although there have been rumours about this for several weeks, the issue gained further prominence due to a question put by shadow DWP secretary of state Jonathan Ashworth to the current DWP secretary of state, Mel Stride on Monday.

Ashworth asked “Can he give a categorical assurance that in the Autumn statement he will rule out means-testing personal independence payment, carers allowance attendance allowance and disability living allowance for children.”

Stride’s response was to avoid answering the question: “The right honourable gentleman is inviting me to break with what has been a very, very long-standing and quite correct convention that when it comes to a major fiscal event, ministers simply do not provide a running commentary as to what may or may not be in that fiscal event.”

In reality that ‘long-standing’ convention was broken as recently as 19 October when Liz Truss told the House at PMQs that the triple lock for pensioners would be maintained.  However, in the same response on Monday, Stride also refused to confirm that the triple lock remained safe under Sunak.

So, at the moment, Benefits and Work can offer no reassurance to readers about what the current administration will or won’t do on 17 November.  All we can suggest is that people don’t assume the worst and instead wait for concrete information.

UPDATE 06/11
Writing about the conservatives budget plans in the Guardian on Sunday, political commentator Andrew Rawnsley quoted a senior Tory as saying “They are flying a lot of kites to see which ones attract most fire.”  

Readers who have strong feelings about the possibility of disability benefits being means-tested might want to contact their MP as a matter of urgency - especially if they are a conservative - to make sure that they are aware that this is a kite which is likely to attract a great deal of fire.

If you do email your MP, please considering posting a comment below and letting us know what you told them. It may encourage other readers to do the same.

UPDATE 15/11
A DWP minister has now said that PIP and DLA will not be means-tested

Comments

Write comments...
or post as a guest
Loading comment... The comment will be refreshed after 00:00.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    VM · 1 years ago
    I don't see the issue here?  Am I missing something?  For them to be means tested, it would mean that people that can afford their care such as the middle classes, wouldn't get any benefits. 

    And for people who have no money and rely on UC/ESA etc, their situation wouldn't change.  So what's the problem here?  Should we give benefits to rich people who can easily afford their care?
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Scots/Scouse ,,, tom · 1 years ago
      @VM Depends what you call rich , at present the cap is £5000 ??? Hardly rich ,,, that's what your allowed to have in savings , plus what about people like me who have worked constantly for 45 years and have a small pension due to having to retire through I'll health ,,,,  what do you think is fair to earn before it's means tested , , , I personally don't think even these morons are stupid enough to commit political suicide but , they don't live in the real world so anything is possible , at the moment anything over £11,500 is taxable even though you have worked all your life and now have a small pension and ESA and pip , so you think that's fair ????
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Jay · 1 years ago
      @VM What do you mean by "rich"? Cos these already very low "benefits" start being impacted as soon as you have a few thousand in the bank. Does a few thousand make you "rich"? I would be penalised because I took a loan to fix a collapsed ceiling. It's not even "savings" as such - as soon as the work is done it won't be in my bank - it's essential work, not optional otherwise the house will be uninhabitable soon - but any means testing would see x amount in my bank and it would go against me
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Ella · 1 years ago
      @Ljn Unfortunately, people on means tested benefits cannot save anyway since benefits are reduced once you have £6000 in savings.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Ljn · 1 years ago
      @VM It would mean people cannot save for expensive equipment, adaptations, or vehicles for example. Even if on an average income the costs of disability are way higher than non disabled and these benefits help bridge some of those costs, they enable lives
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Janet · 1 years ago
      @Sue Johnson I work as a clinician in the nhs part time and care for my disabled husband the rest of the time. We don’t quite make ends meet as it stands. If his pip was means tested we couldn’t financially survive ( we mortgage rather than rent). I would earn too much to  pass the means test.. My husband doesn’t want to “burden me further “ as he puts it. Our options are for me to give up work and cost tax payers more or for us to seperate and tax payers fund him an adapted rental as the kids would need to stay in our home with me. It’s already so hard. We are far from rich. I had 3 cleaning jobs whilst studying at uni and caring for my husband. Really shouldn’t have tried so hard I realise now. 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Lees · 1 years ago
    I'm not going to lie. I'm actually terrified this will happen. Many reasons. My mental health has gone downhill since the pandemic and this news,alongside the financial crisis has all but tipped me over the edge. I'm trying to wait on further info but I'm so sick of this government. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      VikingMermaid · 1 years ago
      @Seels That sounds pretty grim for you right now.  Am glad that you're able to hang on because you recognise that you are loved.  Wishing you strength for your daily battles and a bright light of positivity somewhere in the future.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      VikingMermaid · 1 years ago
      @Rex Please, please, please don't do anything rash, no matter how logical it might appear to you now.  You are not alone in this; and know that your death would achieve nothing other than misery in the hearts of those you leave behind.  Wishing you strength, healing and self-compassion.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Suzy · 1 years ago
      @Rex Hi Rex Please don’t take your own life. 🙏 Life is precious and nothing is ever so bad that we would think of that. We must all fight and vote the Tories out. If they do this, they will be out of Government in a heartbeat.  Stay strong . You are not alone .
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Seels · 1 years ago
      @Rex I understand. I feel the same. Please hang in there. I am managing to hang on by remembering that I am loved and I'd hurt the people I love by not being here. It's a daily battle right now. Sending hugs and strength. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Rex · 1 years ago
      @Lees I feel the same. Totally had enough. Thinking of suicide. I feel 'hunted' by the tories. Have done for 12 years😔Had enough of the fascists
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Michaela · 1 years ago
    After watching P.M. Questions Time it seems to me that Rishi Sunak has to be the most evasive P.M. the country has ever had the misfortune of  having in power.  He spectacularly fails to answer EVERY SINGLE QUESTION put to him by an opposing party and instead relies purely at every single opportunity of attacking the Minister asking the particular question.  The sooner this uncaring, unsympathetic man is out of office, the better.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      VikingMermaid · 1 years ago
      @Jay Me neither.  I thought after the downright awful Johnson and his fly-by-night successor Truss (neither of whom I could bear to watch) Sunak would at least be a little more eloquent and open.  How wrong can you be?  I watched him for a full four minutes on PMQs last Weds and found I couldn't stomach listening to his evasiveness and flannel any more than I could his predecessors.  Rotten to the core, this government.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Jay · 1 years ago
      @Vix Exactly
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Jay · 1 years ago
      @Michaela I honestly can't even face watching PMQs. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Vix · 1 years ago
      @Michaela I think people forget that he was the chancellor throughout covid and it’s prob his and Boris’s fault we are in the mess we are in now. Maybe if they took back all the fraud that was committed in the pandemic or the millions they paid their friends, we wouldn’t have such a big hole in the money pot
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Richard · 1 years ago
    This is a retrograde step.  Upon reflection, I don't think that this will be permitted as it wouldn't save that much anycase.  The truth is, they don't know what to do as every action they take will alienate some of the electorate.  
      I cannot believe that we would see a return of the means- testing that was common place in the early part of the twentieth-century.  The media are spreading misery on a daily basis with headlines about possible benefit changes - it would be better if individual politician's thoughts were kept private.  This cabinet leaks like a collander and reminds me of an episode of Yes, Minister.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Mollie · 1 years ago
    It would be rather hypercritical if they did means-test these benefits as David Cameron claimed DLA for his young disabled son who sadly died and they certainly didn't need it.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Pj · 1 years ago
    Really hope they , the government, give this a lot of thought. 
    It gives everyone that little bit of independence, during the difficult times of disability. To take it away because your spouse earns would be so cruel . Let's face it most people on these benefits can't work. 
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Elizabeth Darvill · 1 years ago
      @A edwards A Edwards  - Absolutely, I am in the same boat, it's terrifying. They pick on sick and disabled people because they can. If we can't pay carers are we supposed to starve and rot in our own mess?

    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Cazz · 1 years ago
      @A edwards I agree with you totally it’s time this government was out of power. They have been picking on disabled people for years many who have worked and paid taxes in the past. It just all reflects on modern society and the view if you are poor or disabled for whatever reason then it’s your own fault. They are out of touch. They shouldn’t have gave away all the money they did during the pandemic and wasted billions. Not to mention lining the pockets of their cronies. It will be a great day when they are gone.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Pj · 1 years ago
      @A edwards Hopefully, if your husband is on a low income , even though they means test it may mean you keep it. 
      Totally agree with you about having enough taken from us. X
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      A edwards · 1 years ago
      @Pj I utterly detest this government,if they means test pip,my income is gone,my husbands 1300 a month wage only covers the bills and not all the bills at that.next it'll be contribution esa,that means the food money gone,we don't ask to be ill,no-one wants to be stuck in not able to leave their home with massive fear and anxiety because they feel so ill,we've already been robbed of careers through illness.isnt that enough!!
We use cookies

We use cookies on our website. Some of them are essential for the operation of the site, while others help us to improve this site and the user experience (tracking cookies). You can decide for yourself whether you want to allow cookies or not. Please note that if you reject them, you may not be able to use all the functionalities of the site.