The DWP’s latest statistics on managed migration to universal credit (UC) showed that almost one in seven claimants had their legacy benefits claims closed and did not complete a claim for UC, potentially losing hundreds of pounds a month.  The DWP have offered no explanation for this, but elsewhere a coroner’s court and a secret report have shed light on the department’s failure to support UC claimants.

The statistics show that between July 2022 and August 2023:

  • a total of 117,690 individuals in 117,190 households have been sent migration notices
  • a total of 61,130 of these individuals who were sent migration notices have made a claim to Universal Credit
  • of those who have claimed Universal Credit, 39,920 households have been awarded transitional protection
  • a total of 40,540 of individuals who were sent migration notices are still going through the Move to UC process
  • a total of 16,020 of individuals who were sent migration notices have had their legacy benefit claims closed

The majority of claimants sent migration notice in this period were single tax credit households.  Most ESA claimants are not expected to be subject to managed migration until 2028. 

The DWP appear to have made no effort to find out why claimants would willingly lose hundreds of pounds a month in income by failing to complete the migration process.  In some cases this may have been a conscious choice. 

However, evidence that not everyone can cope with the process of claiming UC is mounting.

Last week, a coroner issued a prevention of future deaths report after a disabled claimant took their own life because they found the UC claims system too hard to manage.

Kevin Davis had a long history of depression and anxiety.  A psychiatrist who worked with Kevin believed his anxiety had been made worse by the stress of the UC application.

The coroner has written to the DWP warning of the dangers of the long and complex forms that have to be completed which “can be overwhelming for someone with a mental health illness”, the lack of help to complete them and the long waits to speak to a telephone adviser.

You can read more about this tragic case on the Disability News Service (DNS) website.

DNS has also obtained a copy of a report about the difficulty of claiming UC, which the DWP have fought to keep secret for four years.

The “How Effective is Support for Vulnerable Universal Credit Claimants?” report was created by the Prime Minister’s Implementation Unit in 2019 but never published. The DWP had to be forced by a court this month to reveal its contents.

The report concludes that the design of universal credit “is inadequate for vulnerable groups” who therefore need extra help from staff through adjustments and specialist support.

Sadly that support is seldom available.

With hundreds of thousands of disabled claimants required to undertake managed migration in the future, the DWP’s lack of interest in the barriers claimants face is deeply worrying.

Comments

Write comments...
or post as a guest
People in conversation:
Loading comment... The comment will be refreshed after 00:00.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    CaroA · 1 days ago
    I'm sorry you're going through so much with this Michelle this system is so dehumanising and brutal. 

    Some years ago struggling with debilitating health conditions I was with my mother when she died terribly of lung disease.  The staff in the hospice said it was extremely traumatic too. A few months afterwards I had an ESA assessment with a young woman.  I explained that my PTSD and other health conditions were a lot worse since experiencing this and that part of my routine in the morning was just listening to podcasts (in between trying to look after my house etc) to take my mind off the shock/loss etc. That came out in the report as 'she likes to listen to podcasts all day' ..... I sent in a letter of complaint after this which of course was not acknowledged. 

    Something has gone so wrong with this DWP system there needs to be a legal challenge of some sort - group litigation or similar for all they have done to us over so many years! I hope you can get through your assessment as well as possible sending all best wishes.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Michelle · 4 days ago
    I have been given an appointment 3 hours away by public transport in a town the other side of the Humber, even though I live in a city. They have given me this appointment 3 times now, and always for 9am. 

    They know I have MS, constant fatigue and diagnosed ADHD. All things that make getting up at 5am to travel 3 hours, on a route I don't know, on several buses, a logistical nightmare, and basically impossible. I spoke to them last, they said they would note it that it's not appropriate. Now here we are again.

    And let's face it, even if I did manage it, it would be a 6 hour round trip, that would leave me stressed and exhausted.... And they wouldn't write down any facts.... Only has hair tied up, has good rapport, went to school 25 years ago.... 0 points 0 points 0 points...  Why should I put myself through it just for them to call me a liar. They don't care about medical records and facts, just bias and excuses to kick.

    I hate this country, and now they want to descriminate against me more by spying on my bank account... Lol!! The worst thing about my disabilities is the UK government and those they hire to  undertake their inhumane descrimination
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Gambolputty · 4 days ago
    Something that might help people make some sense of the DWP/Tory policy shenanigans. It's sounding a lot more positive than some of the clickbait the Express and Daily Mail are posting.

    https://www.birminghammail.co.uk/news/cost-of-living/dwp-breaks-silence-over-immediate-29137186
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Ben · 5 days ago
    This is a disgusting and reprehensible action from the corrupt government.  They have only just recently changed the policy from DLA and want to make things harder for disabled people, they are now trying remove any support altogether.  

    The the way in which the consultation is presented needs to be challenged, it looks to control responses which then can be interpreted whatever they need to justify their decisions.  Also, more accountibility and transparency in terms of oversight, because it is a well know tactic that they just need to consult but do not need to heed the results of the consultation (mind you not sure what use this consultation is looking for).  DWP are well known for not bothering with process, just look at the usual responses to United Nations Committee for the Rights of Disabled People, regarding the UK’s “grave and systemic” violations of the UNCRDP.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Sandra Bowes-Rennox · 5 days ago
    Disgusting.. It's like asking if you prefer to breathe.. One for the courts I fancy.. TICK TOCK TORIES ⏳⏰
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Karen T · 2 months ago
    I gave been refused PIP and the CAB have persuaded me to go an appeal. I did the mandatory reconsideration and was turned down so now waiting for the tribuna.
    I am almost completely deaf in both ears I also suffer with anxiety IBS and OCD and bladder weakness I only got 2 points at first the 4 with the mandatory reconsideration.
    My adult son with mental health problems lives with me at the moment but he is waiting to go to supported housing. I also drive a car 2 or 3 days a week.
    They put in the report that I drive every day which I do not as I do not have the energy, and so I was worried they would say that I should not be driving. I need my car it is my lifeline, even though I do stay in often and find it difficult to motivate myself sometimes even to get dressed some days.
    I think that I did not make it very clear originally as I found the process very intimidating.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Jules · 6 months ago
    My granddaughter has depression and anxiety, has bad panic attacks, she applied for PIP under advice of her welfare officer last December but has heard nothing . I sent a recorded delivery letter to DWP but have still had no reply - disgraceful 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Mary · 6 months ago
    I have managed to get basic rates for both daily living and mobility for PIP with the help of a Benefits Adviser who is funded jointly by my local CAB and my GPs surgery. I found the help completing the form was invaluable because the Adviser prompted me with supplementary questions to draw out my answers to each of the sections. They then wrote a rough draft which both of us discussed and amended before filling in my final responses. It was also helpful that I was able to make an appointment to meet the Adviser in one of the rooms at my surgery which is a place I feel safe and supported. This meant that I felt able to be very open with the Adviser when explaining how my daily life is affected by my illness and to discuss in detail exactly how best to communicate those points in writing.

    With hindsight I think that the process of needing to explain the details of your illness to another sympathetic and non-judgemental person is very helpful.  If you know someone you trust who is prepared to help you by listening, even if they have no training, the guides published by Benefits and Work could be a very useful aids for completing the form together. If you can discover a Benefits Adviser or Disability Advocate in your own area, even better, especially if you can arrange sufficient time for you to have more than one appointment so that you can think over your initial answers in your own time at home and discuss them with others if you want.

    I do urge everyone who is unwell to gather the strength they need to persevere with the PIP claim process; it is awful and takes a great deal of effort and sheer grit to continue, there's no sugar coating that. However, when you finally receive the money it makes a great deal of difference to your daily life, so please gird your loins and keep on keeping on.
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Emma · 6 months ago
    I applied last August having presented with neurological issues, numbness, tingling, bowel and bladder issues, anxiety, PTSD, diagnosed with Fibromyalgia and joint hypermobility. Pain in feet, hands, vertigo with bouts of debilitating nystagmus, blurred vision all of which I was either under a consultant for or awaiting an appointment. The assessor basically lied about everything during the telephone assessment at the end of March and I received 6 points for using aids which I had purchased. I requested the report and the assessor stated I wasn't under a MH nurse who I've been under since 2020 and 2 weeks after the call made a home visit and increased my medication and referred me for therapy. I've since had a brain MRI and a spinal MRI just this week awaiting results. Being at the mercy of such long wait times to see a consultant and then tests was used against me. I've since suffered bouts of paralysis and have an OT and Physio in place. The OT provided me with four aids which I depend on daily and the physio is recommending I am provided with a motorised wheelchair because of my mobility issues and extreme fatigue. I requested an MR immediately after receiving their decision but my health deteriorated soon after and have been unable to get the PIP evidence I now have, put together and sent to them to counter everything the assessor claimed in the report. I've experienced cognitive issues so brain got and state of mind just to apply myself to this has not been easy as well as being in and out of hospital. I will be sending in as soon as I'm able as I know we have 13 months as advised bu 2 seperate PIP advisors. I shall keep you updated. 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    James · 6 months ago
    I was awarded the basic mobility part of PIP for anxiety, I received 10 points, so this has enabled me to get a blue badge. I have epilepsy and found (like most people) the phone assessment awful, the 'clever' questioning, the lack of knowledge of my conditions just left me completely drained so by the end of the assessment I had no idea what I was saying, I explained to the nurse who did the assessment I had notes to help me as my memory is terrible because of the epilepsy meds. My first question was "do you have any pets?" The daily living part I was awarded 8 points so I have done a mandatory reconsideration, I really didn't have the energy to do the reconsideration but I've made myself. 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Sharon · 6 months ago
    I have tried twice for pip and been turned down, now I have done a reconsideration and getting all my paperwork together. I’m suffering with anxiety, depression and newly diagnosed with Celiacs disease. I’m having help from my Occupational Therapist, I could never do this on my own. 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Carol · 6 months ago
    I'm pleased to say 1st time applying for Pip for my 16 year old daughter who is Autistic but also has severe anxiety. I managed to tell the Pip team that she wouldn't talk so had a telephone call instead of ftf assessment, pointless really when she can't speak. Anyway after a lengthy 2 hour call & an agonising 2 weeks we were awarded Enhanced rate for both, all thanks to this website.
    • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
      Lisa · 6 months ago
      @Carol If you get tax credits make sure you tell them your daughter now gets PIP. 
  • Thank you for your comment. Comments are moderated before being published.
    Gary · 6 months ago
    Having managed to attain the higher rates for both benefits for 9 yrs, this year they decided to reduce my wife's Living allowance by 50% and remove the mobility allowance.